Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Gay brains structured like those of the opposite sex
Randi Rhodes Message Board > Main Forums > Focused Interests > GLBT Issues
Pages: 1, 2, 3
rowdyroddypiper
QUOTE (KaydensMommy @ Jun 19 2008, 02:28 PM) *
While I see your point.... I would also say that it is the audiences fault for putting all gays in the same category. An intelligent person would know that Jesse doesn't speak for all gays. Just like all whites, blacks, women do not think the same... I think we would all be doing the GLBT community a disservice by putting all of you in the same box.


well said
Tyo
QUOTE (KaydensMommy @ Jun 19 2008, 12:28 PM) *
While I see your point.... I would also say that it is the audiences fault for putting all gays in the same category. An intelligent person would know that Jesse doesn't speak for all gays. Just like all whites, blacks, women do not think the same... I think we would all be doing the GLBT community a disservice by putting all of you in the same box.


I think jess aka GayWarrior needs to tone it down a bit. Okay, quite a bit. And it seems like that's what he's doing. I haven't really figured him out yet, but I like him and he makes me laugh.

CowboySteve
Come along, go about your lives, citizens. Nothing to see here.
carmenjonze
QUOTE (GayWarrior @ Jun 19 2008, 11:23 AM) *
I said it in a moment when everyone was being mean to me. I am all for peace, I don't wish anyone dead, plus that particular person compared me and all gay men to the "nazi circa"


Sorry I missed all the fun today and I know they are banned twice over, but this is a LIE.

WTF is a "nazi circa", anyway.

I never said any such thing. Anybody who knows even the BASICS about me sees through it.
QBC
QUOTE (LibLaw @ Jun 18 2008, 12:30 AM) *
Gay brains structured like those of the opposite sex

* 11:13 16 June 2008
* NewScientist.com news service
* Andy Coghlan

Brain scans have provided the most compelling evidence yet that being gay or straight is a biologically fixed trait.

The scans reveal that in gay people, key structures of the brain governing emotion, mood, anxiety and aggressiveness resemble those in straight people of the opposite sex.

The differences are likely to have been forged in the womb or in early infancy, says Ivanka Savic, who conducted the study at the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm, Sweden.

"This is the most robust measure so far of cerebral differences between homosexual and heterosexual subjects," she says.

Previous studies have also shown differences in brain architecture and activity between gay and straight people, but most relied on people's responses to sexuality driven cues that could have been learned, such as rating the attractiveness of male or female faces.

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn1414...s5_head_dn14146


I'm convinced that a person's sexual orientation is hereditary.

Going back to my grandfather's family, there is one gay person (3 males and 1 female) in each of the succeeding generations.
ubabrba
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 22 2008, 06:57 PM) *
I'm convinced that a person's sexual orientation is hereditary.
I am convinced that a person's sexual orientation is decided by multiple factors, heredity being among them.
carmenjonze
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 22 2008, 04:57 PM) *
Going back to my grandfather's family, there is one gay person (3 males and 1 female) in each of the succeeding generations.


So you base your conclusions on flimsy anecdotal evidence?

Bzzzt, wrong answer.
ubabrba
QUOTE (carmenjonze @ Jun 23 2008, 07:26 AM) *
So you base your conclusions on flimsy anecdotal evidence?

Bzzzt, wrong answer.
Who, Peak??? NEVER would he draw a conclusion based upon ancedotal evidence!!! wink.gif
TammyStickers
Homosexuality has been observed in every mammal species. I would think that that was enough proof right there. It is hard to argue that a gay mouse is gay because of poor upbringing.
Stoon
QUOTE (TammyStickers @ Jun 23 2008, 10:50 AM) *
Homosexuality has been observed in every mammal species. I would think that that was enough proof right there. It is hard to argue that a gay mouse is gay because of poor upbringing.

And non-mammalian species as well. Many bird species have been observed to have homosexual relationships.
QUOTE
A pair of male flamingos have become foster parents after adopting an abandoned chick in Gloucestershire.

Carlos and Fernando had tried to start their own family by stealing eggs from other flamingos at the Wildfowl & Wetlands Trust (WWT) in Slimbridge.

But their sitting and hatching skills impressed staff so much, that when a nest was abandoned last week, they were chosen to "adopt" the chick.

The new flamingo family is said to be doing well.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/glouces...ire/6679315.stm

QBC
QUOTE (ubabrba @ Jun 23 2008, 09:01 AM) *
Who, Peak??? NEVER would he draw a conclusion based upon ancedotal evidence!!! wink.gif


I was offering my opinion, which is what everyone else on this thread has done. smile.gif
ubabrba
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 23 2008, 08:06 PM) *
I was offering my opinion, which is what everyone else on this thread has done. smile.gif

I was just teasing you Peak, I like you and I expect I'll learn a lot from you which is the reason I added you to my friends.
carmenjonze
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 23 2008, 05:06 PM) *
I was offering my opinion, which is what everyone else on this thread has done. smile.gif


So again, you base your conclusions about an entire group of people on a personal anecdote?
carmenjonze
QUOTE (carmenjonze @ Jun 24 2008, 12:45 AM) *
So again, you base your conclusions about an entire group of people on a personal anecdote?
























[crickets]


























KaydensMommy
QUOTE (Stoon @ Jun 23 2008, 11:55 AM) *
And non-mammalian species as well. Many bird species have been observed to have homosexual relationships.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/glouces...ire/6679315.stm

What a sweet story!!!
QBC
QUOTE (carmenjonze @ Jun 24 2008, 04:11 PM) *
[crickets]

I'm assuming this was directed towards me. If so I'm not sure what you are looking for. Thus far, several people have weighed in on this thread - offering their opinion. That's exactly what I offered - my opinion.

Based on your periodic responses to my posts, I'm assuming you are dropping by to pull my chain from time to time. smile.gif
QBC
QUOTE (ubabrba @ Jun 23 2008, 07:15 PM) *
I was just teasing you Peak, I like you and I expect I'll learn a lot from you which is the reason I added you to my friends.

Yep I caught that you were teasing me and attempted to reply in kind. I Look forward to seeing you in future threads.
Tyo
QUOTE (KaydensMommy @ Jun 24 2008, 02:15 PM) *
What a sweet story!!!


Who knows how many hetero avian relationships will be destroyed because these two flaming flaunting fairy flamigos are encouraged to fly in the face of fundamental family f.... f... Values?
mitchk224
QUOTE (pestone @ Jun 18 2008, 03:09 PM) *
As long as only your ego has shrunk......... laugh.gif

I've heard gay men's hypothalamus' tend to be larger.
Is that why I can give myself goose bumps on cue? That physical reaction is governed by the hypothalamus....

mitchk224
QUOTE (pestone @ Jun 18 2008, 03:09 PM) *
As long as only your ego has shrunk......... laugh.gif

I've heard gay men's hypothalamus' tend to be larger.
Is that why I can give myself goose bumps on cue? That physical reaction is governed by the hypothalamus....


_______________________________________________________


Perhaps, or maybe your just...cold?

As an aside, I want to add My opinion
about Gay union, Gay marriage, ect.

I want to scream even at Randi about
Gay Marriage, be it MM or FF:

Marriage is NOT a Religious affair. PERIOD.
It is a Government controlled institution, as you
Must get a license from the Government before
you bring your religion into the fray.

So, how can the Government condone Discrimination
AT ALL regarding any two persons obtaining a marriage
license?

This is, on its face, illegal.
Again, Religion has NO part to play in American
Marriage. It is an absolute requirement that a state
must first issue a piece of paper for any one to marry,
and on that form NO state could ask of your religion.

Done.

I have 6 children. All not homosexual, 4 married.
But the obvious lawlessness that abounds in Amerika
stinks to high...somewhere.

ohhh.and, F jackie.
MK
KaydensMommy
QUOTE (Tyo @ Jun 24 2008, 04:37 PM) *
Who knows how many hetero avian relationships will be destroyed because these two flaming flaunting fairy flamigos are encouraged to fly in the face of fundamental family f.... f... Values?

laugh.gif
Tyo
QUOTE (mitchk224 @ Jun 24 2008, 03:03 PM) *
_______________________________________________________



As an aside, I want to add My opinion
about Gay union, Gay marriage, ect.

I want to scream even at Randi about
Gay Marriage, be it MM or FF:

Marriage is NOT a Religious affair. PERIOD.
It is a Government controlled institution, as you
Must get a license from the Government before
you bring your religion into the fray.


You rock thumbsup.gif clap.gif clap.gif
mitchk224
QUOTE (Tyo @ Jun 24 2008, 05:14 PM) *
You rock thumbsup.gif clap.gif clap.gif



Thanks, but please quote the entire message.

I mean, look at all the work I had to put into it...
God, it took me, what...three minutes??

later T
MMK
carmenjonze
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 24 2008, 02:32 PM) *
I'm assuming this was directed towards me. If so I'm not sure what you are looking for. Thus far, several people have weighed in on this thread - offering their opinion. That's exactly what I offered - my opinion.


The question has been, why does such little evidence convince you, leading you to your "opinion"?

Answers?
QBC
QUOTE (carmenjonze @ Jun 24 2008, 05:32 PM) *
The question has been, why does such little evidence convince you, leading you to your "opinion"?

Answers?

First I don't agree that my observation constitutes little evidence. How many families do you know where there is a gay in each of the preceding 4 generations. I don't think this is random and believe it is genetic.

Second, I'm curious why you have singled me out for the third degree. Many of the other opinions offered on this thread have virtually nothing to back them up.

Finally, since this is just my opinion and I'm not offering my opinion up as a fact, I really don't have to convince you of anything.

pestone
I doubt if there is a single factor/cause/gene. I also think there's some type of evolutionary mechanism involved in sexuality. Population pressures, 'food security,' and quality of life must play a part in the mix. This is my opinion, mind you, so don't ask for a link. tongue.gif

Consider this, though: How overpopulated would the planet be if somehow homosexuality just never occurred to mankind, and virtually everyone capable of breeding, did? How crowded would the planet be now? Would we have 10 times more people? 100 times?
carmenjonze
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 24 2008, 06:42 PM) *
First I don't agree that my observation constitutes little evidence. How many families do you know where there is a gay in each of the preceding 4 generations. I don't think this is random and believe it is genetic.


Belief, not fact.

How many families do you know where there are straights in 4 generations?

How come nobody asks these questions about heterosexuality?

QUOTE
Second, I'm curious why you have singled me out for the third degree.


Because you're cute.
egghead
QUOTE (carmenjonze @ Jun 25 2008, 04:38 AM) *
Belief, not fact.

How many families do you know where there are straights in 4 generations?

How come nobody asks these questions about heterosexuality?



Because you're cute.


Peak IS cute. Makes one wonder. tongue.gif
QBC
QUOTE (carmenjonze @ Jun 25 2008, 04:38 AM) *
Belief, not fact.


Exactly, as I have made very clear.

QUOTE
How many families do you know where there are straights in 4 generations?


I only bring up the 4 generations, because the family I refer to is my family.

QUOTE
How come nobody asks these questions about heterosexuality?


I'm assuming this is a rhetorical question. Since I didn't start this thread or any other GLBT thread, you might be asking the wrong person. smile.gif

QUOTE
Because you're cute.


My wife thinks so too. laugh.gif
QBC
QUOTE (egghead @ Jun 25 2008, 04:22 PM) *
Peak IS cute. Makes one wonder. tongue.gif


Do you think I'm cute too? biggrin.gif
justiceforall
I'm gonna go out on limb here and say that I don't believe that being gay is inherited at all. If it was, the gene wouldn't last too long for obvious reasons.

This whole thing about brain size and such reminds me of the way they used to try and predict whether someone would be a criminal back in the early 1900s based on skull type .... body type and it usually described someone of Mediterranean descent....

With homosexuality, the genetic argument is being used to "normalize" homosexuality, and it has become political correct to go along with this theory.
Tyo
QUOTE (justiceforall @ Jun 25 2008, 04:34 PM) *
I'm gonna go out on limb here and say that I don't believe that being gay is inherited at all. If it was, the gene wouldn't last too long for obvious reasons.

This whole thing about brain size and such reminds me of the way they used to try and predict whether someone would be a criminal back in the early 1900s based on skull type .... body type and it usually described someone of Mediterranean descent....

With homosexuality, the genetic argument is being used to "normalize" homosexuality, and it has become political correct to go along with this theory.


so what causes it? And why is it so commonly observed in animals other than humans and why hasn't it died out there? Or did you just forget the click on the sarcasm thing?
QBC
QUOTE (justiceforall @ Jun 25 2008, 06:34 PM) *
I'm gonna go out on limb here and say that I don't believe that being gay is inherited at all. If it was, the gene wouldn't last too long for obvious reasons.

This whole thing about brain size and such reminds me of the way they used to try and predict whether someone would be a criminal back in the early 1900s based on skull type .... body type and it usually described someone of Mediterranean descent....

With homosexuality, the genetic argument is being used to "normalize" homosexuality, and it has become political correct to go along with this theory.


From my grandfathers family extending through to my nieces and nephews, we are probably talking well over 100 relatives. I don't think 4 gays amongst all of my relatives would be considered outside the statistical norm for a genetic argument.
justiceforall
QUOTE
so what causes it? And why is it so commonly observed in animals other than humans and why hasn't it died out there? Or did you just forget the click on the sarcasm thing?


No sarcasm intended. What causes it? Well, here we get into the debate of nuture verses nature, meaning is it caused by conditioning, environment, diet......lot of possibilities. I have read that some scientists believe that a woman who has had more than one son, develops antibodies to some male hormones, or something and therefore the second and third and fourth, with increase likelyhood, will be gay. There is some statistical evidence for this, but it is scanty.

QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 25 2008, 05:07 PM) *
From my grandfathers family extending through to my nieces and nephews, we are probably talking well over 100 relatives. I don't think 4 gays amongst all of my relatives would be considered outside the statistical norm for a genetic argument.

I am not sure what this means. Any genetic trait, in order to be passed along, needs a sexual transmission. I guess it could be some kind of recessive gene.....but I would expect that to be predictable and observable, like blue eyes. There is no evidence of this as far as I know.
QBC
QUOTE (justiceforall @ Jun 25 2008, 07:32 PM) *
There is no evidence of this as far as I know.


I've googled this and agree that there is not much on the subject that has been published. However, I'm thinking the reason for that is that there hasn't been a lot of study in a possible genetic connection as of yet. IMHO

I believe the reason is that until recently, many previous generations kept one's sexual orientation a secret. That is why I don't think there has been a lot of study of the genetic arument.

Again this is all specualtion based on my observations within my family and some brief research that I've done on the subject.
pestone
QUOTE (QBC)
From my grandfathers family extending through to my nieces and nephews, we are probably talking well over 100 relatives. I don't think 4 gays amongst all of my relatives would be considered outside the statistical norm for a genetic argument.

Four that you are certain about. Don't make an ass out of Uma Thurman by assuming all of your relatives are honest about their sexuality. It might be forty, bucko.
pestone
QUOTE (justiceforall)
With homosexuality, the genetic argument is being used to "normalize" homosexuality, and it has become political[ly] correct to go along with this theory.

Bill O' calls it "humanizing" homosexualty. And how is it politically correct to try and determine if sexual behaviors have inherited origins? The scientific jury is going to be out for awhile on this one, anyway. Are you suggesting that we not even attempt to find out? What are you afraid of? You're str8, right? I'm sorry. That was politically correct. You're "normal", right? glare.gif
QBC
QUOTE (pestone @ Jun 25 2008, 07:49 PM) *
Four that you are certain about. Don't make an ass out of Uma Thurman by assuming all of your relatives are honest about their sexuality. It might be forty, bucko.


We recently had a family renunion, where a very comprehensive family tree was constructed and displayed in a very elaborate slideshow that recycled throughout most of the event. The family tree made every attempt to show each family members profile, spouse and siblings. Those family members who were gay, were profiled along with their life partner. No attempt was made to cover any of this up.

It was at this family renunion where I discovered that my grandfather's brother was gay (I already knew about the other 3). Prior to the reunion I didn't really make the 4 generation connection.
carmenjonze
QUOTE (Tyo @ Jun 25 2008, 04:02 PM) *
so what causes it? And why is it so commonly observed in animals other than humans and why hasn't it died out there? Or did you just forget the click on the sarcasm thing?


What causes heterosexuality?
carmenjonze
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 25 2008, 03:01 PM) *
I'm assuming this is a rhetorical question.


No, it's a question designed to point out the double standard when talking about "causes" for this or that.

What is the "cause" of heterosexuality and why do who think The Gay is inherited never stop to ask the same questions about heterosexuality?

It goes back to my post on queer theory a few days ago.
pestone
QUOTE (carmenjonze)
What causes heterosexuality?

Marriage, silly. That's why it has to be protected from us gays.
wink.gif laugh.gif rofl.gif

Wait. What? blink.gif
carmenjonze
QUOTE (justiceforall @ Jun 25 2008, 03:34 PM) *
I'm gonna go out on limb here and say that I don't believe that being gay is inherited at all. If it was, the gene wouldn't last too long for obvious reasons.

This whole thing about brain size and such reminds me of the way they used to try and predict whether someone would be a criminal back in the early 1900s based on skull type .... body type and it usually described someone of Mediterranean descent....

With homosexuality, the genetic argument is being used to "normalize" homosexuality, and it has become political correct to go along with this theory.


Screw "political correctness". PC is bullshit.

Not everybody goes along with the theory which to me is just a bunch of guesswork at this point.

What is not guesswork is the way gays have been treated and the violence and threats of violence used for nonconformists. Those things can be unlearned and stopped. That's just a historical fact.
pestone
QUOTE (QBC @ Jun 25 2008, 06:00 PM) *
We recently had a family renunion, where a very comprehensive family tree was constructed and displayed in a very elaborate slideshow that recycled throughout most of the event. The family tree made every attempt to show each family members profile, spouse and siblings. Those family members who were gay, were profiled along with their life partner. No attempt was made to cover any of this up.

It was at this family renunion where I discovered that my grandfather's brother was gay (I already knew about the other 3). Prior to the reunion I didn't really make the 4 generation connection.

I'll even take back the bucko, bucko. laugh.gif
jkun17
So what.

Things get wired funny in development. Even before development things can get wired funny, genes cross over creating mutations. It happens more often than you think. It's usually harmless but more often than not it changes things.

Anyone who has even cursory knowledge of genetics shouldn't be surprised by this.
carmenjonze
QUOTE (jkun17 @ Jun 25 2008, 09:06 PM) *
So what.

Things get wired funny in development. Even before development things can get wired funny, genes cross over creating mutations. It happens more often than you think. It's usually harmless but more often than not it changes things.

Anyone who has even cursory knowledge of genetics shouldn't be surprised by this.


Monosexuals are the ones who are wired funny lol

Apparently it's a dominant trait.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.