OK, OK - enough with the flood of PMs pleading for an anlysis of McCain's speech like that which I offered of Palin's! Here you go!
-----------------------------------------------------
On some facets of McCain's speech, it seems I disagree with several of my RRMB colleagues.
Judged on a spectrum that runs the gamut from Lincoln, JFK and MLK through Reagan, Clinton and Obama, McCain's speech was clearly awful. If the spectrum is limited to Mccain's past performances, and those of other speakers at the convention over the last couple of days, I thought his presentation was better than most. MAYBE his best.
But I'm among those defectives who maintain that a candidate's speechifying is really only a shallow, petty credential. Sure, I understand that, realistically, it's important to the process of getting elected. But I remain open to one day voting for a geeky, nervous, sweating, stumbling goof who vomits before he addresses large crowds as long as I believe he can kick ass in the office he's running for, and his priorities and analyses and plans inspire and please me.
There's little question the speech came in three parts. (I know, most folks say 2 parts - they're wrong.)
The first part of the speech was the pro forma thanks to his family, Palin and other candidates who spoke in the last couple of days.
For example:
QUOTE
As always, I'm indebted to my wife, Cindy, and my seven children.
Then he went on to reach out to real people, and to let them know he understand their concerns - or at least that he's heard the hoots of laughter about the basic issues that have been unmentioned at the convention before now. He talked about health insurance woes, economic concerns, and those other topics that tell folks he really DOES kow what they're worried about.
Here's an example of that:
QUOTE
I fight for Bill and Sue Nebe from Farmington Hills, Michigan, who lost...lost their real estate investments in the bad housing market. Bill got a temporary job after he was out of work for seven months. Sue works three jobs to help pay the bills.
In the second third of his speech, McCain spelled out some of his plans, and told some flat out lies about Obama's plans. For example, it apparently doesn't matter how many times Obama spells out his tax plan, McCain et al are going to continue insisting he plans to raise taxes for most "average" folks.
e.g.:
QUOTE
...My tax cuts will create jobs; his tax increases will eliminate them. ...
In the final third of his speech, McCain recounted his POW experience in detail - the same detail most of us have heard at length, and described the ways in which it changed his outlook on life. (How he's changed his mind on so many issues over the years was not explained.)
From the POW hunk:
QUOTE
Through taps on a wall, he told me I had fought as hard as I could. No man can always stand alone. And then he told me to get back up and fight again for my country and for the men I had the honor to serve with, because every day they fought for me.
Though you may not hear it from anyone else, I believe the speech as a whole was inspiring and impressive to any person who has never heard of John McCain, and to those who knew absolutely nothing about him before this evening. And sharing something in common with literally all of the other speakers throughout the RNC, it would also be very important for the listener to be unaware that Republicans - McCain's party - has held the White House for the last 8 years.
Only those "in the know" could appreciate the irony of McCain and all the others demanding "CHANGE" from the very folks they put into office in the first place. It would also help to be unaware the extent to which the same party has controlled Congress for more than a decade. And all that's without even mentioning McCain's flip-flops on issues running the gamut from torture, to the Bush tax cuts.
Here's an example of that which MUST impress and please the voter who knows nothing:
QUOTE
I'm not -- I'm not in the habit of breaking my promises to my country, and neither is Gov. Palin. And when we tell you we're going to change Washington and stop leaving our country's problems for some unluckier generation to fix, you can count on it.
And we've...
We've got a record of doing just that, and the strength, experience, judgment, and backbone to keep our word to you.
The only danger McCain faces in that statement is making it in front of anyone who knows better. Oddly, I kind of thought most in the audience DID have reason to know better. On the other hand, they showed no sign of appreciating the irony.
As I watched the crowd jumping and screaming at every mention of grabbing Washington DC by the scruff of the neck and shaking it, or reducing the size of government, and so forth, I wondered how many of those folks have those ridiculous "W" stickers on their cars back home. I wondered why none of THEM wondered about McCain's claim up against the fact that he'd voted to support George Bush's agenda more than 90% of the time (95% in some years over the last 4).
For the wholly ignorant person, I really do think many of McCain's words were inspiring and uplifting. That portion of the speech wherein McCain asked others to join him in the fight was especially inspired.
QUOTE
My friends, if you find faults with our country, make it a better one. If you're disappointed with the mistakes of government, join its ranks and work to correct them. ...
Fight with me. Fight with me.
Fight for what's right for our country. Fight for the ideals and character of a free people.
Fight for our children's future. Fight for justice and opportunity for all.
If only it hadn't come from McCain, or if the request hadn't been made of a hall full of Republicans.
Come on, you gotta admit - that's great rhetoric. If only it hadn't come from McCain. For example, imagine those words coming from Obama!
For everyone who knows him, and his audience, I think it was kind of embarrassing. Nonetheless, the audience did not seem to be at all embarrassed. I admit, this mystifies me.
LINK TO THE SPEECH TRANSCRIPT